The cost-effectiveness of preventing type 2 diabetes or, more generally, of preventing cardiovascular disease (CVD) in people who are at high risk (such as those with diabetes) has been investigated. The results are highly encouraging. A recent study 1 concluded that lifestyle intervention was cost effective in all age groups and cost-saving in those aged 25-44 years. Metformin intervention, while cost effective in younger age groups, was not cost effective in those aged over 65 years.In low-income countries preventing diabetes by means of lifestyle intervention is likely to be highly cost effective. Other methods to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease in people at high risk are also attractive from the humanitarian and economic points of view. Another study 2 found that a number of population-based and person-based interventions to lower blood pressure would be cost effective in all regions of the world. Some of the results are shown in Table 1. Costs in international dollars (ID) per Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALY) saved range from below ID200 in countries such as Egypt, Iraq, Pakistan and Yemen to around ID1,500 in the wealthier countries of Europe, North America and Australasia.
Table 1 | Cost-effectiveness of a combined preventive strategy by region*
| Region |
Cost (x106) |
DALY-SAVED |
Cost/DALY-saved |
Example nations |
|
|
ID |
(x105) |
ID |
|
| AFRICA | ||||
| High adult and child mortality |
733 |
18 |
400 |
Algeria, Nigeria, Ghana |
| Very high adult and high child mortality |
543 |
17 |
320 |
Botswana, Eritrea, Uganda, United Republic of Tanzania |
| THE AMERICAS | ||||
| Very low adult and child mortality |
12,783 |
91 |
1,410 |
Canada, Cuba, United States of America |
| Low adult and child mortality |
2,056 |
58 |
350 |
Argentina, Colombia, Mexico |
| High adult and child mortality |
298 |
5 |
650 |
Bolivia, Ecuador, Guatemala, Haiti |
| EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN AND MIDDLE EAST | ||||
| Low adult and child mortality |
789 |
21 |
380 |
Iran, Libyan Arab Jamahiriya, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia |
| High adult and child mortality |
952 |
52 |
180 |
Egypt, Iraq, Pakistan, Yemen |
| EUROPE | ||||
| Very low adult and child mortality |
15,474 |
99 |
1,570 |
Belgium, Denmark, Italy, Spain, United Kingdom |
| Low adult and child mortality |
NA |
88 |
310 |
Bulgaria, Poland, Turkey |
| High adult and low child mortality |
4,198 |
176 |
240 |
Estonia, Hungary, Russia, Ukraine |
| SOUTH-EAST ASIA | ||||
| Low adult and child mortality |
733 |
20 |
360 |
Sri Lanka |
| High adult and child mortality |
2,994 |
95 |
310 |
Bangladesh, India |
| WESTERN PACIFIC | ||||
| Very low adult and child mortality |
NA |
42 |
1,320 |
Australia, Japan, Singapore |
| Low adult and child mortality |
6,072 |
158 |
388 |
China, Philippines, Republic of Korea, Samoa |
*Mean Expected Annual Costs (ID2000), Disability Adjusted Life Years saved, and Costs/DALY-saved for a combined programme of salt-reduction, mass media health education, and four-drug therapy for all citizens with CVD risk > 25%.
NA not available
Adapted from Murray et al, 2003 2
As has been pointed out 3 , there is little direct (i.e. RCT) evidence that people at high risk selected specifically on the basis of other risk factors (those with a family history of diabetes, for example) can benefit from these (or other) interventions. Also, with the exception of the STOP-NIDDM trial 4 , none of the recent trials have directly demonstrated a reduction in risk of cardiovascular disease consequent upon the reduction in risk of transition to type 2 diabetes. (Although the Diabetes Prevention Program has demonstrated a reduction in surrogate risk factors 5 ). However, it could logically be argued that those with other risk factors should benefit and that cardiovascular risk should be reduced if the progression to diabetes can be delayed.
Additional to this possible benefit is that the early diagnosis of type 2 diabetes enables surveillance of the development of microvascular complications to be initiated and their treatment to be started if this is available and appropriate. If these preventive goals are realized, the potential health benefits, both to the individual and to society, are enormous. As a result, the global profile of diabetes would be transformed.
1.Herman,W.H. Hoerger,T.J. Brandle,M. Hicks,K. Sorensen,S. Zhang,P. Hamman,R.F. Ackermann,R.T. Engelgau,M.M. Ratner,R.E. The cost-effectiveness of lifestyle modification or metformin in preventing type 2 diabetes in adults with impaired glucose tolerance. Ann.Intern.Med..2005; 142(5): 323-332
2.Murray,C.J. Lauer,J.A. Hutubessy,R.C. Niessen,L. Tomijima,N. Rodgers,A. Lawes,C.M. Evans,D.B. Effectiveness and costs of interventions to lower systolic blood pressure and cholesterol: a global and regional analysis on reduction of cardiovascular-disease risk. Lancet..2003; 361(9359): 717-725
3.Tuomilehto,J. Modeling of primary prevention of the development of type 2 diabetes. Przegl.Lek..2006; 63 Suppl 4: 3-6
4.Chiasson,J.L. Josse,R.G. Gomis,R. Hanefeld,M. Karasik,A. Laakso,M. Acarbose treatment and the risk of cardiovascular disease and hypertension in patients with impaired glucose tolerance: the STOP-NIDDM trial. JAMA..2003; 290(4): 486-494
5.Ratner,R. Goldberg,R. Haffner,S. Marcovina,S. Orchard,T. Fowler,S. Temprosa,M. Impact of intensive lifestyle and metformin therapy on cardiovascular disease risk factors in the diabetes prevention program. Diabetes Care..2005; 28(4): 888-894

contents
browse
